Phantom Thread Review - Den of Geek

Phantom Thread is the second film to come out this fall in which a tortured artist puts his work above all else, including the love of a beautiful, devoted woman. In the case of Darren Aronofsky’s mother!, which arrived in September, the story was treated as both extended metaphor and surreal fever dream, inciting profoundly visceral responses in the viewer. But with Phantom Thread, writer/director Paul Thomas Anderson has produced a sedate, rather passionless look at a similar subject that continues the filmmaker’s recent predilection for making films that remain curiously unengaged with the audience on any number of levels, including emotional.

Don’t get me wrong: Phantom Thread has many things going for it, including a typically detailed and meticulous performance from Daniel Day-Lewis (which he says is his last), fabulous production design and cinematography, a haunting score from Jonny Greenwood, and a marvelous supporting turn from Lesley Manville. There are also nice bits of humor sprinkled throughout the film, much more than one might expect initially. But the core of the movie–the relationship between Day-Lewis as fashion designer Reynolds Woodcock and Luxembourgian actress Vicky Krieps as his lover/muse/tormentor–never really rises beyond a pseudo-Gothic tit-for-tat that lacks electricity.

It’s the 1950s, and Woodcock is the dressmaker to the upper echelons of London society, working out of his magnificent townhouse with an army of assistants presided over by his devoted sister Cyril (Manville). The latter runs the house and the business like a tight ship; even the women who provide brief sojourns of companionship for Reynolds are treated like employees and dismissed when no longer needed. That is until Reynolds meets a waitress named Alma (Krieps) on a weekend seashore retreat. Smitten on sight, he brings her into his controlled and ordered life only for her to become a more disruptive influence than he ever imagined, with his health and business hanging in the balance.

That makes Phantom Thread sound a lot more exciting and juicy than it actually is. While Day-Lewis is excellent, he doesn’t quite let us under Reynolds’ skin; he’s a collection of tics and eccentricities more than a fully-rounded character. Asked by Alma why he’s never married, he only laughs. We get the sense that he really only lives for his work, which makes the attraction to Alma all the more perplexing. Krieps seems passive-aggressive throughout, even in one surprising sequence where the film almost takes a turn into thriller territory. It’s a strange sequence that opens the door for Phantom Thread to plunge into darker, more perverse realms, but Anderson never quite gets there.

You May Like Also

  • Share on Facebook (opens in a new tab)
  • Share on Twitter (opens in a new tab)
  • Share on Linkedin (opens in a new tab)
  • Share on Facebook (opens in a new tab)
  • Share on Twitter (opens in a new tab)
  • Share on Linkedin (opens in a new tab)
  • Phantom Thread Trailer: Daniel Day-Lewis Goes High Fashion for Final Film
  • Jennifer Lawrence Gave Phantom Thread “Solid 3 Minutes” Before Turning It Off
  • Oscars 2018: Den of Geek Reviews Best Picture Nominees
  • The Best TV Shows of 2021